better-ed
HomeUse CasesPricingPrivacy & TrustFAQContactAbout
LoginSign up for free
better-ed

Empowering educators with AI-powered voice assessment tools. Hear every student think—without doing more work.

LinkedInFacebookYouTube
CompanyAboutTeaching TipsBlogUse CasesPrivacy & TrustPricingFAQChangelog
Finland

Lapinlahdenkatu 16, 00180 Helsinki

Philippines

Unit 3006, One Corporate Centre, Julia Vargas Ave., Ortigas Center, Pasig City

© 2026 better-ed. All rights reserved.

Privacy PolicyTerms of ServiceCookie PolicyDelete account
All tips
FEEDBACK

Comment on the decision, not the answer

"Why did you pick this method?" teaches more than any mark in the margin.

Jul 21, 2026 · 1 min read

Most margin comments describe the answer: right, wrong, unclear, good. The comments that change future work address the decision behind the answer: the method chosen, the evidence selected, the order attempted. Decisions are what the student controls next time. The feedback research says the same thing: feedback aimed at the process of the work transfers to future tasks far better than feedback aimed only at the task itself (Hattie & Timperley, 2007).

In practice

  • Swap "wrong" for "what made you choose this method here?", written as a question the student must answer, not a rhetorical one.
  • Praise decisions too: "Choosing to test with easy numbers first: keep that." Praised strategies get reused; praised answers don't generalise.
  • One decision-comment per piece beats five answer-comments. Pick the decision that most shaped the outcome.
  • This is also AI-proof feedback: a generated artefact contains no decisions, which becomes obvious the moment you ask about one.

Quick takeaway: answers end with the task. Decisions carry into the next one.

More on feedback

FEEDBACK

Make them name what they want feedback on

A cover note saying 'check my paragraph transitions' turns your marking from broadcast into reply. Replies get read.


1 min read
FEEDBACK

Praise the strategy, not the person

'You're so clever' is the comment most likely to backfire. Point the praise at what they did, not what they are.


1 min read
FEEDBACK

Point at the gap, don't write the fix

Feedback that rewrites the sentence does the thinking for them. Feedback that names what is missing makes them do it.


1 min read