Make them name what they want feedback on
A cover note saying 'check my paragraph transitions' turns your marking from broadcast into reply. Replies get read.
Nov 12, 2026 · 1 min read
Feedback is read differently when it answers a question the student actually asked. Requiring one line on submission, 'the thing I want feedback on is...', forces a moment of self-evaluation before handing in, and hands you a marking shortcut: respond to their question first, then add at most one observation of your own. Students who cannot name a target yet are telling you something equally useful. (Manning's metacognitive-prompt-library skill generates task-specific versions of exactly these self-evaluation prompts, calibrated to how practised the class is at reflecting.)
In practice
Task: [describe the task and year group]
Write six cover-note prompts students complete when
submitting this task, in two sets:
Set A for students new to self-assessment: prompts
pointing at concrete parts of the task.
Set B for practised students: prompts asking them
to judge quality against the criteria.
Each prompt must be answerable in one sentence and
specific to this task, not generic.- Add one compulsory line to every submission: 'I want feedback on...' plus 'the part I am least sure about is...'.
- Answer their question first in your comment, visibly. Uptake rises when the first sentence proves you read their note.
- Ban 'everything' and 'nothing' as answers. Offer a menu of three task-specific options for students who freeze on the blank line.
- Track the requests across a class: if half the cover notes name the same worry, that is next lesson's starter, not thirty identical comments.
Quick takeaway: feedback lands better as a reply than a broadcast.