better-ed
HomeUse CasesPricingPrivacy & TrustFAQContactAbout
LoginSign up for free
better-ed

Empowering educators with AI-powered voice assessment tools. Hear every student think—without doing more work.

LinkedInFacebookYouTube
CompanyAboutBlogUse CasesPrivacy & TrustPricingFAQChangelog
Philippines

Unit 3006, One Corporate Centre, Julia Vargas Ave., Ortigas Center, Pasig City

Finland

Lapinlahdenkatu 16, 00180 Helsinki

© 2026 better-ed. All rights reserved.

Privacy PolicyTerms of ServiceCookie Policy
All tips
AI INTEGRITY

Make the AI argue against itself

Ask for the answer, then ask for the strongest case that the answer is wrong. The gap between the two is where the judgement lives.

Sep 15, 2026 · 1 min read

Models agree too easily, with you and with themselves. A useful classroom counter-move: after any substantive AI answer, require the follow-up "now make the strongest case that what you just said is wrong or incomplete." Where the self-critique is weak, the original was probably solid; where it lands a real punch, the student has found the claim that needed checking, and practised the adversarial reading that transfers to every source. (Manning's ai-expertise-interrogation-designer skill builds full routines on this.)

In practice

  • Make it a standing pair of prompts for research tasks: answer, then counter-case, then the student writes two sentences adjudicating.
  • The adjudication is the assessable part: which points of the counter-case stick, and how would you check?
  • Anything the counter-case flags as factual and checkable goes through lateral reading (see "Teach lateral reading on AI citations").

Quick takeaway: one answer is information. The answer plus its strongest rebuttal is an exercise in judgement.

More on ai integrity

AI INTEGRITY

Require one doubt, one check, one source

A standing rule for every AI answer: one place it could be wrong, one way to check it, one non-AI source to consult.


1 min read
AI INTEGRITY

Have students log what the AI did for them

After an AI-assisted task, one honest question: which parts could you now do alone? The answer calibrates them better than any rule.


1 min read
AI INTEGRITY

Assess the chat, not just the essay

On AI-open tasks, the transcript is where the thinking lives. Ask for it, and grade the questions they asked.


1 min read